Yi-Fu Tuan's Topophilia: A Study of Environmental Perception, Attitudes, and Values argues that because humans are the "ecological dominant," understanding the environment requires first understanding human behavior in depth, so that we can see how our attitudes, beliefs, passions and values shape and are shaped by the environment. This claim that human perception and experience is an important component of the environment and a valid geographical topic is in direct response to the scientific reductionism of post-WWII geography; it seeks to bring human culture back into the "practical" study of the environment by putting "topophilia," or "the affective bond between people and place or setting," at the center of geographic research.
Although Topophilia intentionally does not have a stated method, it does have a theoretical framework. Tuan sets out to examine environmental perception and values at the levels of the species, group, and individual; to hold culture (or topophilia) distinct from the environment to show how
Showing posts with label individual. Show all posts
Showing posts with label individual. Show all posts
Monday, April 8, 2013
Sunday, April 7, 2013
100: James Duncan's Superorganic
In "The Superorganic in American Cultural Geography," James Duncan calls out cultural geography for laboring under an outdated and undertheorized concept of culture, and argues that cultural geographers and social geographers would both benefit from interconnections between their disciplines.
According to Duncan, cultural geographers in the 1970s (the essay was published in 1980) were largely still working from Carl Sauer's "superorganic" theory of culture in his 1925 essay "The Morphology of Landscape." Building on the work of Berkeley anthropologists Alfred Kroeber and Robert Lowie, Sauer theorized culture to be both autonomous and the determinant of individual human action. This separation of the individual from culture causes several problems for cultural geographers because
According to Duncan, cultural geographers in the 1970s (the essay was published in 1980) were largely still working from Carl Sauer's "superorganic" theory of culture in his 1925 essay "The Morphology of Landscape." Building on the work of Berkeley anthropologists Alfred Kroeber and Robert Lowie, Sauer theorized culture to be both autonomous and the determinant of individual human action. This separation of the individual from culture causes several problems for cultural geographers because
Friday, April 5, 2013
82: Clay Carson's In Struggle
Clay Carson’s In Struggle: SNCC and the Black Awakening of the 1960s uses the trajectory of
SNCC’s radicalism in the 1960s both to analyze the black civil rights movement
as a historical struggle and to draw conclusions based on this struggle about
social movements more generally. He
divides SNCC’s history into three broad segments: formation of a grassroots
organization around the dual foci of non-violent protest strategies and
socioeconomic programs to help poor rural Southern blacks; organizational
centralization and internal strife related to a deepening understanding of the
extent of structural racism in the United States and conflict over whether
separatism or interracial collaboration would best address it; and a turn
toward generating black power ideology and away from social programs that
resulted in the failure of SNCC and a dissipation of the civil rights movement
more generally. As Carson assembles oral
histories, meeting transcripts, newspaper accounts, and other sources into this
general narrative, several historically contingent conclusions emerge. First and foremost, Carson argues that the
black civil rights movement (as SNCC) was most successful at effecting social
change early in the movement, when it was able to balance individual interests
with collective rights – hence Ella Baker’s “group-centered leaders” instead of
“leader-centered groups.” Further, developing an ideology is important for
sustaining a mass movement, but this ideology has to come from the ground up,
not from the top down. Hence, SNCC lost
its constituency when it moved away from localized social and economic programs
and toward flashy Black Power rhetoric.
And finally, Carson argues that radical separatism will not achieve
social equality as well as interracial cooperation or cooperation with more
liberal groups, both because it overemphasizes individualism and because it has
little basis in the material reality of most potential constituents. Carson’s history thus makes a compelling
argument for grassroots activism and a federated structure as two
characteristics of a successful social change organization.
Wednesday, January 30, 2013
28: Lynn Hunt's Inventing Human Rights
In Inventing Human Rights, Lynn Hunt links the development of universal human rights - the idea that all people, as a rather formative American document puts it, "are created equal" and have "certain unalienable rights" - to two 18th-century events: the French Revolution and the rise of the epistolary novel.
The French Revolution resulted in the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen, which argues for the existence of a universal humanity - "man" - and the necessary connection between the rights of this universal body and the body politic. If that language feels a lot like that in the Constitution, that's because it is: universal humanity and equal rights were both Enlightenment concepts, and the framers of the Constitution were Enlightenment men.
But the novel? Hunt argues that novels, which didn't even exist before the 18th century, were hugely important in the construction of human rights because they created a sustained, intimate relationship between the reader and characters whose lives were very different from their own. In particular, epistolary novels - especially ones about women - drew readers in with the most intimate details about characters' lives; if reading through fictionalized correspondence seems pedantic today (er, it does to me, anyway), back then, this extended snooping allowed readers to become familiar with, even attached to, people they had nothing in common with. Arguing that familiarity breeds empathy, Hunt finds in the novel a necessary corollary to abstract concepts like "universal" and "equality:" individual empathy. This empathy, she says, is necessary for universal human rights to work, since you can only see another person as an equal when you can see yourself in them.
Hunt thus puts a very human face on universal human rights. While she could pay a little more attention to the lives of non-readers and the complex power structures in which they live and work, in this book she still provides a compelling intellectual and cultural history of a very formative idea.
The French Revolution resulted in the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen, which argues for the existence of a universal humanity - "man" - and the necessary connection between the rights of this universal body and the body politic. If that language feels a lot like that in the Constitution, that's because it is: universal humanity and equal rights were both Enlightenment concepts, and the framers of the Constitution were Enlightenment men.
But the novel? Hunt argues that novels, which didn't even exist before the 18th century, were hugely important in the construction of human rights because they created a sustained, intimate relationship between the reader and characters whose lives were very different from their own. In particular, epistolary novels - especially ones about women - drew readers in with the most intimate details about characters' lives; if reading through fictionalized correspondence seems pedantic today (er, it does to me, anyway), back then, this extended snooping allowed readers to become familiar with, even attached to, people they had nothing in common with. Arguing that familiarity breeds empathy, Hunt finds in the novel a necessary corollary to abstract concepts like "universal" and "equality:" individual empathy. This empathy, she says, is necessary for universal human rights to work, since you can only see another person as an equal when you can see yourself in them.
Hunt thus puts a very human face on universal human rights. While she could pay a little more attention to the lives of non-readers and the complex power structures in which they live and work, in this book she still provides a compelling intellectual and cultural history of a very formative idea.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


