Thursday, April 11, 2013
157: Susan Strasser's Never Done
Strasser is interested in what 19th century housewives actually did and what technologies they really used, not in the history of the technologies per se; the date that most households seemed to have a particular kind of technology and how most housewives seemed to use it are a lot more important to her than the date the technology was patented or the technological innovations that went into it or when the first privileged few got ahold of it. Therefore, she uses new social history methodologies to access her subject. Her sources include reformers' reports on intolerable living conditions, government documents on standards of living, sociologists' descriptions of daily life, manufacturers' market research, ads, catalogues, travel accounts, letters, and advice manuals, cookbooks, and women's magazines. In all of these sources, she's looking not so much at the opinions or prescriptive advice but at the ways in which particular technologies and practices are framed - as new, old-fashioned, commonplace, etc. This strategy allows her to approximate what American housewives' lives might have been like at different points in time form 1850 to 1930.
Strasser structures her book topically rather than temporally. She traces the shift in food production from the consumer to the factory by studying transportation systems, refrigeration, mass distribution (followed by mass production), and improvements in canning techniques and packaged foods that made dietary variety more available to the urban poor and fresh produce available to the rich year round, while rural women continued to produce everything themselves. She studies changes in cooking technology, from open grates to cast-iron stoves and eggbeaters, but argues that most women would not have had access to time saving equipment in the 19th century. She shows how electricity reduced the winter work of chopping and carrying wood and tending fires, and indoor plumbing dramatically reduced women's work by relieving them of carrying water. She also discusses sewing machines, servants, childrearing, separate spheres, restaurants and a host of other topics.
Yet while Strasser often seems to celebrate the additional time freed up by a new technology, her title "Never Done" is apt. With each new labor-saving technology, women became less attached to the community of women who labored together; they also became detached from their families, as products increasingly fed, cared for children, and provided affection in place of women. Never Done thus relates to two things: the ongoing creep of capital into our everyday lives, shifting our attention to consumption and away from each other; and the ongoing fight by the women's movement to shift the emphasis from individual consumers living in separate spheres to a "consolidated sphere" where both genders work together to regain mutual love, respect and community outside of capitalism.
Considering that the vast majority of the book is descriptive, this normative feminist statement at the end is a bit jarring. At least identifying the enemy as capitalism rather than the patriarchy makes sense in the context of her discussion of industrial capitalism's effects in the home.